Feng Shui Sorcery and Fu - a big, bad sin?
From: Master_Kiero Posted on: 5/4/2003 10:33 am
To: ALL
Message: 203.1
Are they an especially deadly combination for PCs? Seems to be big no-no for any starting character to have the two things together. This is reflected in the difficulty of most Fu-using characters to learn Sorcery (most have no Magic score, and of course there's the whole apprenticeship gig). Conversely, most of the Sorcery-using characters have no Fu, and no Martial Arts ability, though to be honest their is probably not as difficult.

Only three archetypes offer the potential for development into Fu and Sorcery-using characters, without attunement (making Attribute boosting a possibility).

The Magic Cop already has a Fu of 2, and Martial Arts of 12 (apparently accidentally left out). So all he has to do is learn some Fu powers, which are cheap. But he'd need some serious XP to boost his Fu attribute for anything more than first level schticks.

The Scrappy kid has a Fu and Sorcery of 7, so depending on which juncture they're from, they could develop the other. Being a kid, the whole apprenticeship thing isn't such a big issue. Not least if there's a PC Sorceror to learn from. More of a power-house to be, rather than initial one. But the "Scrappy Kid all grown up" could be seriously powerful. Anyone ever run a campaign long enough for one to grow up? Or had some magical intervention do so?

The real potential Sorcery-monster is the Old Master. He already has a Magic of 10, so presuming he could stomach apprenticeship, he'd start out with a non too shabby Sorcery of 10. Along with his already kick-ass Martial Arts and Fu ability.

Anyone had any experience with these issues? Is it a big deal?

Kiero

From: Queex Posted on: 5/5/2003 6:22 am
To: Master_Kiero
Message: 203.2
in reply to: 203.1
I haven't come across it too much in my campaign. The only example was the Sorceress buying Fox's Retreat.

To be honest, I think there ways of abusing the system in not fun ways with Fu. Some of the schticks are just too powerful. I think the GM should use his judgement when PCs get any sort of schtick to see if there's some dreadful abuse in the offing.

From: Sensei Posted on: 5/11/2003 1:41 pm
To: Master_Kiero
Message: 203.3
in reply to: 203.1
I haven't had a great deal of experience with this yet, but looking at it strategically, I don't think it would be as big a problem as some might fear.

I mean, the XP spent to increase Magic or Fu scores, and/or to pick up Fu -and- Sorcery shticks in combination would otherwise just be spent to increase the individual stats for one of these abilities, or to increase the level of schticks in one of these categories. If a PC is spending XP in both areas of these skills, then the level of skill with *each* is going to be diluted, and therefore not as potent as some of the other characters who specialize in either Sorcery -or- Fu singularly.

In other words, having Fu and Sorcery together may sound powerful, but a PC having both will have lower scores/ fewer schticks for each area than a PC spending XP to increase just one skill will have for that area. I feel that one character with maxed-out Sorcery skills OR maxed-out Fu abilites would be more dangerous than a PC who has average (or below average) skills in BOTH areas.

Since I only have one Magic Cop, who just began playing, I haven't seen any examples of potent Fu/ Sorcery combos, but I'll keep ya updated.

From: eXceL111 Posted on: 5/23/2003 7:36 am
To: Sensei
Message: 203.4
in reply to: 203.3
Any character not specialised in martial arts and with some fu can use the Norton utilities since they are cheap in Fu.

I have seen Sorcerers start with a chi of 2. The 2 Luck points are always useful, and 3 xp (=1 adventure) will give you Willow step twice per sequence. This is hardly gamebreaking though since the sorcerer is better off developping his sorcery henceforth.

As for the magic cop, I like the archetype because I like versatile and well rounded characters, but as far as game balance, I have found them not to be a problem. Their highest AV is so low that they will have difficulty with any other archetype in straight combat. Moreover, their versatility often means that there are other more specialised players better at what he does whether sorcery, martial arts/fu or guns. This is especially true if there is a Sorcerer with Summoning and his other schtick in the group.

Finally, the combined schticks presented in golden comeback are rather innocuous (IMO) and expensive to develop. If your GM is cool with it though, invent your (better) own. I think that would be the way to go to take full advantage of the Magic cop versatility and uniqueness.

Looks like this is more a magic cop post then a Sorcery/Fu one...

From: BillionSix Posted on: 5/26/2003 1:11 am
To: eXceL111
Message: 203.5
in reply to: 203.4
Actually, the Taoist Wizard starts out with Chi 5 (Mag=8). His beginning schticks are Influence, plus either 2 Sorcery schticks or 2 Fu schticks.
This is a character template actually designed to mix Sorcery and Fu.

Brian

From: Bob the Dancing Monkey Posted on: 6/11/2003 11:44 am
To: Master_Kiero
Message: 203.6
in reply to: 203.1
As I think has been mentioned before, the Scrappy Kid All Grown Up is a really scary notion. One of the little bits of Netherworld quirk that I've added to my game is Georgi's book on people surviving in the Secret War - I've put into the players' heads that children in the Netherworld don't tend to survive long.

In part, my rationale of this is that Innerwalkers realize that kids who are in the War tend to be unstoppable if underestimated for too long. Nonetheless, in our version of the Netherworld, there are two Scrappy Kids who have made it...one who has taken something of a prestige class (Monster Hunter/Slayer), and one who is simply The Young Master.

From: Bob the Dancing Monkey Posted on: 6/11/2003 12:38 pm
To: Bob the Dancing Monkey
Message: 203.7
in reply to: 203.6
There's a part of me that would almost want to run an All-Scrappy Kid campaign, or an All-Scrappy Kid All Grown Up campaign. You know, have the Scrappy Kid Who Was Horribly Mutated Into An Abomination, the Scrappy Kid Who Found Out She Was The One, the Scrappy Kid Who Now Works At Ninja-Burger, the Young Master, and of course the group's mascot, the Uber-Kid.
From: Queex Posted on: 6/12/2003 6:04 am
To: Bob the Dancing Monkey
Message: 203.8
in reply to: 203.7
How about the Scrappy Kid with terrifying sorcerous powers who spent twenty years at the bottom of a well and has now sworn vengeance on the rest of humanity?
From: Bob the Dancing Monkey Posted on: 6/12/2003 9:03 am
To: Queex
Message: 203.9
in reply to: 203.8
Exactly.

Now here's a question - did all FS characters start out for all intents and purposes as Scrappy Kids?

Annie Dao, L'il Ting Ting, Kar Fai's son Kar Fai...how cute must Desdemona Deathangel have been when she was just growing up?

From: GrifterX2 Posted on: 6/13/2003 3:26 am
To: Bob the Dancing Monkey
Message: 203.10
in reply to: 203.7
Now I'm tempted to reenact The Goonies. Think about it. You've got your lil techie, your lil big bruiser, and so on. I thought that movie was perfect, but now I realize it can be improved by the addition of Kung Fu.

Grifter

From: Bob the Dancing Monkey Posted on: 6/13/2003 8:27 am
To: GrifterX2
Message: 203.11
in reply to: 203.10
Grifter, all film can be improved by kung fu.

_Sense and Sensibility_? Add Kung Fu and you have _Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon_.

_Dark City_? Add Kung Fu and you have _The Matrix_.

_Dracula_? Add kung fu and you have _Blade_.

I mean, just imagine what kung fu can do for _Fargo_. Or _Bringing Up Baby_. Or _How To Marry a Millionaire_.

From: Sensei Posted on: 6/13/2003 11:53 pm
To: Bob the Dancing Monkey
Message: 203.12
in reply to: 203.11
Oddly enough, ANYTHING can be improved with the addition of kung fu!

"If you look at diagram 13-A on the quarterly financial interim reports, genetlemen, you'll note that while short-margin merchandise profits are down, our kung fu is up twenty percent this fiscal period."

"Sugar Charms Cereal! 100% the recommended daily allowance of iron, vitamins, and kung fu!"

"For a limited time only, every McDaniel's Happy Meal comes with specially packaged kung fu!"

And don't get me started on Sorcery...