Feng Shui just bought the book...
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/6/2004 3:27 pm
To: ALL
Message: 334.1
havent read through it much, but if its anything like whats been described to me, and like how Rune was set (simplistically), then im pretty sure im gonna like it


Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/7/2004 10:54 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.2
in reply to: 334.1
There's verrrry little not to like about the game!
And then, you get to buy... the supplements!

Wooo HOOO!

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/7/2004 11:43 am
To: Sensei
Message: 334.3
in reply to: 334.2
hah... well i have read some more through the book, and have noticed that it refers to theuse of 2d6 (one negative, one positive)... is this for all rolls the character every makes?


Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/7/2004 10:40 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.4
in reply to: 334.3
Yep. It's one of the simplest systems I've ever come across.

And I've got a LOT of games and a LOT of systems, my friend.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/7/2004 10:42 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.5
in reply to: 334.4

i just read the section talking about it... so basically, FS uses 2d6 (positive/negative) then you add whatever score to it... where Rune uses 1D10 and functions like Ars Magica (so i am told)..

 

ok, i think i can handle this..lol

 

i do play Rune, so no use trying to explain it..lol



Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/11/2004 10:11 am
To: ALL
Message: 334.6
in reply to: 334.5

how do i figure out shot costs?

 

is it just a trial and error thing, or is there sort of a guideline list to follow by?



Visit my Art Website
From: DarrinBright Posted on: 2/11/2004 11:55 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.7
in reply to: 334.6
The Feng Shui mechanic is a little more complicated than rolling 2d6 and subtracting the negative die from the positive. Each die "explodes" on 6 (explodes is a industry term to reroll and add to the previous total), so you can wind up with positive and negative values above or below 30... well, technically the upper and lower bound are infinite, but the highest roll I've seen was 40-something.

When you roll "boxcars" (two sixes), then something special or dramatic happens, and you reroll both dice. If the next roll is positive, then it's usually considered a critical success. If negative, then a critical failure.

There are also some rules for snake-eyes, but I don't recall the particulars offhand... I think double ones means your gun jams, or if you're using arcanowave, you make a mutation check.

Shot costs are easy. Any standard action takes 3 shots. Making an attack, rolling a skill check, or running across the room is 3 shots. Certain actions take fewer shots, such as active dodges (parrying, diving behind cover), snapshots, putting a fresh clip into a pistol. Really long actions, like reloading a revolver, brain surgery, etc., take more shots.

Note: rolling for initiative in Feng Shui is not like making an attack or skill roll. It's a "closed roll", which means you don't reroll and add sixes, and you only use 1d6+Speed. (The 1st Edition Daedelus book actually used open rolls for initiative, but that was a little unfair/obscene for some people.)

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/11/2004 2:12 pm
To: DarrinBright
Message: 334.8
in reply to: 334.7

uh, yeh, ok..lol

 

i just need shot costs... it was a bit vague, thats all... i did read more on the rolls... the problem comes from the fact that it talks about information, before giving it to you...

 

like for instance it talks about shot costs, but doesnt go into detail about them until later on in the chapters.. its just an odd layout i guess



Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/15/2004 2:54 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.9
in reply to: 334.1
By the way, Prophet, you'll want to go to Atlas Games' home page and download the missing archetypes that were left out of that printing of the book (thief, journalist, magic cop, etc.)
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/15/2004 6:57 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.10
in reply to: 334.9
umm... they are in my book... i had downloaded them though, but they are in my book..lol


Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/16/2004 5:03 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.11
in reply to: 334.10
Huh. Well, I'll be a cybernetic monkey's uncle. You must have a different version of the rules than I do. Lucky you.

But I'll bet YOU don't have a prototype homemade working model of the hand held gravity distorting utility tool like I do, do you? Huh? Do you?! HA! I thought not!!

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/16/2004 8:43 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.12
in reply to: 334.11
nope... but i have the real thing..lol


Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/19/2004 10:19 am
To: ALL
Message: 334.13
in reply to: 334.12

couple questions now

if a character doesnt start with sthicks from the template, he can only get them with experience.. right?

in the start of the Fu chapter,, it mentions that you get fu shticks eqaul to your kung fu or chi ratiing... what if after creation, a templated character that started with 0 chi, got more chi... like say 3... would that allow him 3 fu scticks.... or would he be able to pick them up later in game, by way of experience?

 

 



Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/19/2004 6:14 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.14
in reply to: 334.13
> "if a character doesnt start with sthicks from the template, he can only get them with experience.. right?"

A new PC starts the game with only the number of schticks listed on his archetype, yes. (So, for example, Killers start with 5 Gun schticks.) They can buy more schticks using XP later on, yes.

>"in the start of the Fu chapter, it mentions that you get fu shticks eqaul to your kung fu or chi ratiing"

I think you've misread; you get the starting number of Fu schticks listed on your archetype (just like other schticks), NOT a number of Fu schticks equal to your Chi. (Your chi is spent to *use* the individual schticks, but that's not the same thing.)

Just as Gun schticks above, new Fu schticks are bought with XP.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/19/2004 11:55 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.15
in reply to: 334.14
ah.. thanks for the clear up.... also.. one of my players has mentioned something from the breifing i downloaded, that mentions if someone was swinging a sword at him, his passive dodge would be his guns ability (he he had them out and was using them)... is this so, and if not, or if so... whats the justification, or the correct method... just curious


Visit my Art Website
From: DarrinBright Posted on: 2/20/2004 8:11 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.16
in reply to: 334.15
Your passive dodge is whatever your highest combat skill is. The combat skills are Martial Arts, Guns, Sorcery, Creature Powers, and (I think) Arcanowave.

So the Killer, who has a Guns of 15 and no other combat skills, his passive dodge is 15.

If you've got an archetype with multiple combat skills, like a Magic Cop with a Guns of 13 and a Martial Arts of 12, then you use the highest.

The justification (or at least the thinking behind it) is that characters are always trying not to get hit regardless of what else they are doing, and this is part of their combat training. So any combat skill confers this passive ability.

There are some exceptions when characters use a parry as an active dodge, but it doesn't come up all that often.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/20/2004 10:21 am
To: DarrinBright
Message: 334.17
in reply to: 334.16
ok doke


Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/25/2004 7:02 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.18
in reply to: 334.17

hey... would it be possible for you to post me some samples of a PC doing a snapshot action.... i didnt fully understand it from the book....

 

ok... i know you can reduce the shot cost by doing an action recklessly... but a few samples would make me understand it a bit better



Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 2/25/2004 10:25 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.19
in reply to: 334.18
A snapshot is just a way of saying that they take less time to do something, at an AV penalty.

It would be something like "firing from the hip". Your Killer gunslinger doesn't take time to aim or even bring the gun up to normal firing level, but rather opens fire just as the weapon clears his holster. This would make the action faster, but less accurate.

Perhaps instead of aiming carefully at the Mook's vital parts, your ninja leaps across the bar, recklessly hurling throwing stars in the general direction of the enemy as he's in mid-air. Again, faster, but less accurate.

Per the rules, it takes three shots to throw an object. But what if your Ex Special Forces guy simply -kicks- the live grenade back towards his opponent instead of picking it up first? Snapshot!

Your techie sweats over the ticking bomb. Normally she could suss out the proper connections to cut, but with only a scant few seconds left on the timer, the techie just starts snipping wires frantically in hopes of diffusing the C-4. Snapshot.

From: DarrinBright Posted on: 2/26/2004 8:18 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.20
in reply to: 334.18
My group doesn't use them much (possibly because I didn't explain them well), but snapshots can be used to squeeze an extra action into the last few shots in a sequence.

For example, if a character has only 3 shots left, if he attacks he uses all three shots and doesn't get to act again for that sequence. If the same character attacked with a 2-shot snapshot (-2 AV), then he gets to act again on shot 1 with a full 3-shot action.

How the action is described is up to the player, but in general a snapshot means the character isn't taking as much time to aim or prepare for the action, firing from the hip, feinting a move, etc.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/26/2004 9:16 am
To: DarrinBright
Message: 334.21
in reply to: 334.20

kinda like the reflex throw at the end of big trouble in little china..lol

 

 

ok not exactly... lol.... when i first read that section, i first thought of matrix bullet time.... but i was pretty durn sure i read it wrong..lol



Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/26/2004 9:24 am
To: Sensei
Message: 334.22
in reply to: 334.19

alrighty, thanks...lol, im planning on getting an FS game going this sunday... i'll have some fairly creature players... a few who complain about a game being all combat, but seem very interested in FS because of the actual story and descriptive element to it.

 

i will be adhering to the "oh... i hit it.......ME: oh... really... ok roll... you miss"... thing.... i really like that whole part about raising the difficulty when someone just says "i hit him"... instead of describing it... i have one player whos notorious for playing martial artists in other games (D&D and Ninjas and Superspies)... and generally will just say "ok im going to hit him..." at least in N&S he uses whats listed in his martial arts.. but still "I hit with with a ... umm... lets see.. a crescent kick.... whats that?"... its obnoxious sometimes.... though..lol, i know what it is, i have taken Taekwondo for many years



Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 2/29/2004 10:24 pm
To: ALL
Message: 334.23
in reply to: 334.20

did my first actual Feng Shui game today... only had two players (one played a ninja, the other a karate cop)... i ran them through an abridged version of the first half of Baptism of Fire, from the book...

 

all in all, character creation took about 35 minutes, game tiome was about 3 hours, with a 15 minutes pause between the first fight, and the next section..

 

im heavily modifying the plots and all, to match an idea i had.. nothing major, and no major departure from the style, just some different plot hooks here and there..

things went well... the only questions i have are:

1.) on skills it has an equals sign, and the book says that cant go above that certain rating at character creation.. others have a "Max" number by it... do those "Max" ratings mean they can never go higher than that?

2.) is it just me, or can you get some wildly high martial arts skills very quickly...the guy playing the karate cop has a +10 in the martial arts skill, and a +8 coming from agility... so thats a fairly high bonus..lol



Visit my Art Website
From: dsprag Posted on: 3/1/2004 1:28 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.24
in reply to: 334.23
I had the same question when I first got the game. Here's how it works, when you just have a number in parentheses, that's the AV you'll have if you don't increase the base attribute or skill bonus, when the number in parentheses is preceded by an equals sign the AV starts there and can't be raised further, and when you have a number preceded by the word Max the AV starts off lower than that and may be raised up to but not beyond that point. Hope that helps.
From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/1/2004 2:10 am
To: dsprag
Message: 334.25
in reply to: 334.24

uh... that doesnt make sense then...

 

the eqauls sign (as mentioned in the book) says that the skill cant be raised above that in character creation... never says its eqaul to that... if that was the case, then why would it list something like:

Martial Arts +9 (=12)

the base skill is +9... and cant go higher than 12... or am i totally off on this..



Visit my Art Website
From: Queex Posted on: 3/1/2004 5:25 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.26
in reply to: 334.25
The base skill _bonus_ is +9, but the final _action value_ is 12. The convention in the Feng rule book is to put the 'bonus' followed by the Action Value. So, if a character has Agility of 9, then their Martial Arts is still 12, but the bonus is actually only +3.

To be honest, the bonus is hardly worth remembering- only the AVs are used for rolls and improvement through experience. The only time the bonus is significant is for subskills (like surgery) which I've never had call to use anyway.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/1/2004 7:52 am
To: Queex
Message: 334.27
in reply to: 334.26

ok...

im not sure which of my questions you are answering though.... i have to assume you are trying to answer both..



Visit my Art Website
From: Queex Posted on: 3/1/2004 8:03 am
To: prophet118
Message: 334.28
in reply to: 334.27
"Martial Arts +9 (=12)

the base skill is +9... and cant go higher than 12... or am i totally off on this.."

A couple of examples:

A character template has REF 5, and Martial Arts +10 (=15).

So, your Action Value is 15, and the skill 'bonus' is +10. But, if you use points during character creation to raise REF to 8, then you have:

Martial Arts +7 (=15)

So the bonus actually goes down if you raise the stat when you create your character.

Example 2:

A template has MND 5, Fix-it +3 (9) [Max 10].

If you increase MND to 7 during character creation, then you will have:

Fix-it +2 (10).

HTH

From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/1/2004 8:12 am
To: Queex
Message: 334.29
in reply to: 334.28

you have an interesting way of doing things... i would have never thought to penalize the skill just because someone puts points in the base stat...

 

im going to go back and read that section of the book today... and see whats going on...



Visit my Art Website
From: CCAMFIELD Posted on: 3/3/2004 12:16 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.30
in reply to: 334.29
That's the way it works...

It's not really a penalty to the skill per se. The bonus value - +10, or +7, or whatever - doesn't matter in comparison with the total. You don't improve skills by increasing the bonus value, you improve them by increasing the total (AV).

It's to prevent players from taking, I don't know, a Killer, and then putting 4 points into Reflexes (I don't know if Killers can put 4 points into an attribute, I'm just writing off the top of my head here), and ending with a 19 in Guns. Which would make them so much more badass than other characters it would totally imbalance the game.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/3/2004 12:26 pm
To: CCAMFIELD
Message: 334.31
in reply to: 334.30
oh... so that part that says add bonus skill points literally means, add skill bonuses in the skill bonus section on the sheet..,. that doesnt get figured into the actual skill rating?


Visit my Art Website
From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/3/2004 12:27 pm
To: CCAMFIELD
Message: 334.32
in reply to: 334.30

its a bit hard for my to think, thats all... hope this doesnt get anyone angry or anything..lol

 

so basically, that little max, or cant go higher than thing, says that the AV cant go higher than that... or is that the actual restriction on the skill

 

 



Visit my Art Website
From: Sensei Posted on: 3/3/2004 5:54 pm
To: prophet118
Message: 334.33
in reply to: 334.32
Bear in mind this all applies only to character creation. After you play and get some XP, you can always raise the AVs above the =/max limits.

The "=" sign means that when you create the PC, the AV is already that number, and cannot be raised higher.

For example, the cyborg starts with a Ref of 5 and a Guns skill of +8, so her total Guns AV is 13. On the archetype, it's listed as "=13", which means that it cannot be raised above this, even if you increase the cyborg's Reflexes during PC creation (and it would be useless to give her more Guns skill levels, since this would do nothing as well).

This is different than "max" in that the archetype starts with an AV -lower- than the listed max number, and you may raise a number to that max, just not *beyond* that max.

For example, Big Bruiser has a Ref of 5 and a Guns skill of +3. His current Guns AV is therefore an 8. However, there's the note of "[Max 10]" after this, which means that you could raise the total Guns AV two more points, by either increasing his Ref to 7 or by adding two skill bonuses to his Guns skill. Either way (or a mixture of both) would raise the Guns AV to 10, which is the max possible, but you couldn't raise it beyond that.

From: prophet118 Posted on: 3/3/2004 7:06 pm
To: Sensei
Message: 334.34
in reply to: 334.33
oh... i understand now... damn D&D..lol


Visit my Art Website